An Edited Interview
This interview was conducted for the podcast Fotinos Thalamos · Φωτεινός Θάλαμος
Hosted by Dimitris Hantzaras
A Greek podcast about photography, art,
and their impact on society.
Interviewer
I wish you an enjoyable listen. Dear listeners, welcome to an episode that is particularly special to me. Of course, every episode is special, and I am genuinely happy to have the opportunity to meet and talk with every guest, but today's episode is a particular pleasure. This episode was originally scheduled for November, but there was a technical problem, a delay, with the October episode. So you will hear November's episode in October and, I hope, October's in November.
Today, then, I have the pleasure of speaking with one of Greece's best known and most important teachers of photography, Mr Platon Rivellis. I should tell you that I was never personally a student of Platon Rivellis. But I have read his books, watched his videos and lectures, and, although we had never spoken before recording this episode, I really felt I was speaking to my teacher. That is how I think of him: as my own teacher. To me, Platon is someone who brought knowledge about photography, and a way of thinking about it, from abroad to Greece.
He brought photography in Greece closer to what was happening in Europe and influenced many generations of photographers. I don't want to say any more by way of introduction. I'll let you listen to him. Enjoy my conversation with Platon Rivellis.
From Law to Photography
Platon Rivellis
As you may have heard, I studied law, which bored me to death. I had no idea what to do. I went to France to study political science. That bored me too. Greece was still under the dictatorship. I came back to do my military service, and then I said, "I'll work as a lawyer to make a living." I didn't like practising law at all. Not at all. But very quickly I realised I could earn a living from it, and quite comfortably, especially if you had some idea how to go about things and weren't a complete idiot. So I lived very comfortably, very nicely, for ten years, but I suffered terribly. I was bored.
I had no children, and I wanted to enjoy life. My father had died, and I told my mother, "I'm giving up the law." And she said, with great love and generosity, "My child, whatever you decide, you'll manage it." But I had no idea what to do. It may sound funny, but I had never owned a camera, even though photography was very important to me. My father loved photography. He didn't just take pictures of us; he would talk about them too, in a wonderful way.
I had collected photographs from my family and relatives, from all through my life, an enormous number of photographs, without owning a camera myself. At one point I fell in love with the woman who became my wife, and she had a camera. I got one too, learned how it worked and immediately, with the excess that is so characteristic of me — and by excess I mean both its good and its bad sides — I built a very fine darkroom in my house. I taught myself to develop and print, and while I was still working as a lawyer I began making photographs of my own.
To learn photography I started buying books. First I bought magazines from various countries, in every language I knew. Unfortunately I don't speak German. I even cut out articles and made books of what I read in the magazines. Then I began buying books. Books were a great passion of mine. Eventually my collection exceeded 4,000 volumes, beautiful and expensive books from which I learned photography.
When I finally stopped buying them, because computers and all the rest were arriving, I donated that entire collection to the Benaki Museum, which had hosted me for many years. Only after giving it away did I learn how valuable many of those books were, how many editions had gone out of print, and that I might have made some money from them. Anyway, it was through those books that I learned. My first idea, while I was still practising law, was to set up an office, a place where I would gather people and teach them what I had learned about photography.
In other words, as I was learning I was trying to teach, and at the same time to keep learning myself. It was a very happy time. But I was trying to leave law behind and become a teacher. I hadn't graduated from a university of photography. I contacted an American school in Athens, and they agreed that I could run a photography school on my premises. All sorts of things happened that made us laugh. For example, a lesbian association suddenly came along, a whole group of women who all wanted to learn photography. We had a lovely time, we laughed and enjoyed ourselves.
But I wanted to do something more permanent, more stable. Since I had gathered a few good students, we decided to found an association. Meanwhile, I was wondering how to earn the money I needed to live on. My first idea — which fortunately never came to anything — was to open a bookshop. But I had a place in a very good location in Kolonaki. It was my home. I moved into a much smaller flat and turned the previous place into a photographic equipment shop.
Unfortunately I was an absolutely dreadful businessman. And ever since then I have had the deepest admiration for people in business — I mean that without a trace of irony. Those who go bankrupt, and there are many, perhaps simply didn't know the trade very well, like me. I managed to have one of the best-known shops in Greece, full of people. I had, what can I say, lots of employees. Profits: zero.
Money came in and went out. People stole from me. There weren't security cameras in those days. Everyone stole from us, customers, friends. We even put some of my students on watch to see who was stealing, and people kept stealing anyway. Half the employees were students of mine, too. I'm used to these things by now; they no longer surprise me. At some point, after five or six years, my accountant said, "Look, you can't go on like this. The shop is ticking along, but if you ever want to close it, you won't have any money left." So I decided to close it.
I must be the only person who had a shop full of customers, realised it wasn't doing well, and shut it down as readily as he had opened it. Meanwhile I had begun to become known as a photography teacher, and I found the courage to devote myself to that alone. I say this as though it were something extraordinary: when I began teaching photography, there was just one other photography teacher, a classmate of mine from primary school, who died about a year ago.
I forgot to say that, at my age — I'm over eighty — my mind obviously isn't what it used to be. I don't remember everything. It was Xanthakis. Xanthakis was a schoolmate of mine, worked in a bank, and was the first to teach photography classes, although his were classes on photographic history. He knew a great deal about the history of photography in Greece. I was the first to concern myself "professionally", in inverted commas, with the art of photography. I say "in inverted commas" because I was never a successful professional.
I was able to start partly because I was among the first. Good schools invited me to teach secondary-school children. Eventually I stopped because I was tired of going from school to school. By then I already had many students who came very regularly to our space on Tsakalof Street. At first I taught forty-day courses, then courses lasting the whole year. And more and more people kept coming.
We had set up a wonderful darkroom where the students worked, people young and old, men and women, from every walk of life. Needless to say, my financial failure was confirmed yet again, because after many years my accountant said to me once more, "Close it down. You're constantly losing money."
Once again everybody stole from us. But with my rather spoiled background and habits, with no financial security at all, yet also no obligations — no children, for example — I enjoyed myself, and things kept moving. Moving, moving, moving. At some point, when the new technology appeared, I tried to learn it. That was far more difficult for me, because I belonged to the older generation.
Just imagine: we had darkrooms — don't ask me how many, I can't remember exactly, but there were a great many — with superb, terribly expensive equipment. Everyone had a wonderful time. We played music, organised evenings together, invited people to speak. We became fashionable; everyone knew about us.
Some people even thought we were a little snobbish, because we were in Kolonaki, because we had black curtains so that people couldn't see in from the street. They called us snobs. Fine, we accepted the label, but we had lots of people. Eventually I told them, "Carry on without me." We had also opened a bar, entrusted it to someone, and that too went spectacularly wrong financially. Imagine having a bar in Kolonaki and having to shut it because it was a financial disaster!
And because I liked change, my wife — who was always my partner in photography as well — and I suddenly decided to take a leap: keep that base going and move ourselves to Syros. I had no connection at all with Syros, but I liked it. I chose it because it was close to Athens and had a hospital. I've always been very fond of doctors, so I said, "Well, if there are doctors there too, let's go." By then the new technology had advanced so much that very few people still used the darkroom.
So I said, "Look, we have this enormous space and we're not making use of it. I'm going to sell it and move to Syros. Whenever you're ready, we'll make the change." Meanwhile I contacted the Benaki Museum, where they had a great deal of affection and respect for me, and they said, "We'll host you for free. You can give your classes here and we won't charge you anything." So I said, "Friends, if you want, keep the space, or let's all rent a different space together and carry on."
Otherwise, the Benaki Museum would host us for our classes and make space available in its other building for meetings and presentations — all completely free of charge.
I need hardly tell you that when you invite people to take part in a decision instead of telling them what to do, when you say, "Let's discuss it together," you can sometimes be surprised. Some of them said, for instance, "We can't go to the establishment." All right, the Benaki Museum is offering us a space for free, but it's the establishment! Well, I decided to go anyway. We had a very good time. The Benaki Museum looked after us splendidly. We could do what we wanted, exhibitions, presentations, all free. I was very fond of it; the affection was mutual, and the museum supported me enormously.
When the Circle moved there, they embraced me and said, "At last, we have you here too." It felt like my own home. Many were delighted, others turned up their noses. I closed up my place in Athens and moved to Syros, where I created a lovely space designed for students to come for summer workshops. We had an enormous area with a darkroom, which also fell out of use because of technology, and we held summer workshops in the countryside.
Again, I tell you, all of this involved spending money without expecting to make any. After all, I had no children. And it all went well. Eventually I grew older. Things changed. That was when I donated my library to the Benaki Museum. With the pandemic I decided to change how I taught. Every cloud has a silver lining: I would never have dared to do it without the pandemic. Just think, from 2000 until the pandemic, every single week I took the ferry and taxis, and kept a rented flat in Athens, just to give my classes.
Another terribly expensive choice. My wife stayed on Syros while I travelled back and forth to teach. And fortunately — fortunately in the sense I mean it — the pandemic came along and I said, "So I can stay at home!" That was the beginning of teaching students remotely, by Zoom, which was a revelation for us. We had a marvellous time. For the first time — and I want to stress this — I enjoyed seeing progress. I want to underline that, because anyone who listens to this conversation will understand it.
Those few who can endure listening to it, that is. But I had been doing something wrong. It's astonishing to reach this age and say, "I've been doing something I love for so many years, but I've been doing it the wrong way." I'll explain what I mean when I finish this introduction, this long introduction. And it's funny: you get to a great age, you're tired, you can't bear to do so many things, but that is when you see more clearly. For the first time, the students were coming in large numbers, partly because they were isolated during COVID and had nothing much else to do.
Most of them got into the habit and kept coming. They didn't have the trouble of taking buses to get somewhere. So I was able to see continuous development. Before that, people would come and listen. I would talk away — and my chatter was rather more enjoyable then than it is now — they would listen, the class would finish and they would say, "Bravo, what a lovely time we had!" Very few ever showed good work; very few carried on. They would say, "Well, we've heard Rivellis, now we'll go and do something else, learn a foreign language, for instance."
Now, for the first time, I had photographers who persevered and who, in a way, needed me. The workshops on Syros had been a bit of a luxury; very few people came once a year. Still, since I had the space, I enjoyed that too. So now, although I'm genuinely tired and have some of the health problems that come with old age, photography is still my joy. I'd say I've become a little wiser, a little calmer, and if someone takes photography and teaching away from me, little by little I'll wither away.
In short, this is my life, a fairly selfish one. But I often tell young people — and I say it with real love, since I have no children to help — that each of us makes our own life. I tell all parents this too, because I'm old now and can afford to give my students who have children a piece of advice: stop giving advice! I once wrote an article that may be my most popular. I wrote for Ta Nea and regularly for various other newspapers.
Because I liked it. I did it all for free. That's why they wanted me: I was free! I wrote an article called "I Love You, and Well Done." In it I said, in essence, "I don't have children, I don't know what it's like to have children, but because I had such wonderful parents, I'd like to offer parents one piece of advice: the only thing they need to do is tell their children every morning, 'I love you, and well done.'" Especially today, when parents are so far removed from the way their children think, children need love and encouragement, not advice.
The article became so well known that employees would pin it to the walls of their offices. "I Love You, and Well Done" became a sort of slogan. And precisely because I was lucky enough to have parents like that, I tried to convey the same thing to my students. You should do all this with love, with joy. How you make a living, how you earn money, whether and how you have children — those are different matters.
Let's not mix up our art, our joy, our emotion, with the practical necessities of life. They are unavoidable, and I can't help you with them except by offering love, nothing more. Now I sound like a preacher, but I always believed this, and at my age I believe it more than ever. The great joy I came to experience — a joy I didn't have at first — was this. At first perhaps I was flattered by people's admiration. It's a mistake we all make, men especially. But in reality those people came and went.
Very few really understood what I was saying. Some copied it and then changed direction completely. Now I'm tiring both you and the listeners who will hear us. But since I've got going, I'll speak frankly. I was happy when people came; I was happy when they showed me respect and admiration — I wouldn't dare say love, that's a big word — but most of them actually had ambitions beyond photography.
A great many of them became teachers. Teaching is very hard and exhausting, whereas the healthy thing, really, is to want to be a photographer, to want to make photographs because you love photography. Why did so many photographers suddenly appear? I tell you again, when I began there was virtually no one. That's difficult for someone starting photography today to understand. Why? Because photography is easy.
Technically easy. In the past there were difficulties: you had to learn to print, there were expenses, every roll of film cost money. In the old classes, before digital technology, very few people brought me photographs during the year. Not everyone did. They enjoyed listening, but they didn't sit themselves down and actually make photographs. And those who did brought only a few. We pinned them on a board, I commented on them, made students choose, and little by little they learned.
No one, however intelligent, can understand in the first year which of their own photographs are good. A teacher is tempted to offer explanations, but that's really just a form of comfort. No one understands straight away. Someone brings you a photograph they think is very good, and you have to tell them, as delicately as possible, that no, it isn't, and reject it. And that is a blow to their ego.
I remember a story. I forgot to mention that I spent a short period, five months, in America. I said to myself, "If I'm going to teach, I ought to get some idea of what photography really is." America was the only country where I could gather so much information in one place. I had spent all the money I'd made in law. I'd enjoyed myself, bought my house, but there was nothing left. A dear friend, who envied the freedom I'd made for myself, said, "I'll give you the money to go to America." So I went to America and met plenty of idiots — it was a photography centre, after all — but I also met two extraordinary people: a young photographer to whom I owe a great deal, who later left the profession, and Garry Winogrand, a major figure. We became good friends, so good that he said, "I'll come to Greece and we'll take photographs together." Unfortunately he died the following year.
The first day we had a critique with Winogrand's group, who were all about my age, he chose two of my photographs, and I was very proud. But he rejected another one that the others liked very much.
I said nothing; at least I had the intelligence to keep my mouth shut. The other students said, "But why didn't you like that one of Platon's? It's a wonderful photograph!" Winogrand's answer is what I'd like to say to my students. He said, "Platon will understand."
When someone brings you a photograph and you reject it, it would be absurd for them to say, "Ah yes, I understand." They'd be lying. They have brought it to you believing it might be good, and you tell them, "No, throw it away." They can't simply accept that on the spot. They have to get used to the idea that, with time, they'll understand. Many students have come back to me years later and said, "How I used to pester you, and how patient you were. You were so right!" I tell them, "That's how it is. It's not easy to say 'I understand.'"
Most people, men especially, demand praise straight away. Unfortunately — and I say this because I have seen it happen — most of the new teachers take advantage of that to attract students, and because they haven't the courage to decide whether a photograph is bad or not. I'll explain what I mean by "bad." So most people, if they weren't immediately satisfied, would leave, either trying to play the game on their own or looking for a teacher who was more easygoing than I was.
"More easygoing than me" meant that Rivellis was obsessed with his own ideas, or terribly conservative, or whatever else. So for a long time I found myself in situations that didn't give me the pleasure with which I'd started. But I had gathered momentum, and things kept rolling. As you can see, I talk too much. No need to say any more.
Interviewer
I'm enjoying every minute.
Photography, Poetry, and Art
Platon Rivellis
At one of my talks, someone said that the one thing Platon doesn't know how to do is press the "stop" button. And I always overrun my classes, simply because I hope to help, or to pass on what I know. Perhaps because I don't have children. What can I tell you? I don't know why. Now, this problem of photography is like poetry. And I think that if you want to help someone understand what photography is, poetry is the best tool. Let me try to explain, in case I can help some listener who can put up with all my chatter.
Interviewer
They can, they can, I assure you.
The Image and Memory
Platon Rivellis
All the arts are suffering today. Cinema, painting, everything is suffering. And I find it rather sad. Why are they suffering? Because the arts have moved into museums and, above all, into institutions of higher education. The idea of going to university to study art seems absurd to me. In the old days people went to work as assistants to a painter they admired. You don't have to go to university to become a photographer. For heaven's sake! For heaven's sake!
I too was offered a position in a School of Fine Arts, and I said no. I didn't want it. It would have given me nothing extra, merely social prestige, and that doesn't interest me. Fortunately, there's no money in photography any more. You can't become a photojournalist; there is no need for photojournalists any longer. Photographs arrive at newspapers for free. Newspapers no longer have salaried photographers. So what does the artist do? He tries, supposedly, to behave like a painter.
When photography became fashionable, some very pleasant women who knew me approached me. They said, "Mr Rivellis, could you help us by telling us what to do about photography?" I said, "What do you mean?" "We don't know how to judge photographs." I said, "Choose what you like. Decide what you like." I don't know; there is no other way. They were very nice women. They knew nothing at all about photography, but gallery owners from Europe and elsewhere had told them that photography was fashionable.
Because it costs less than painting, it is decorative, it can be sold. So they plunged straight in and naturally began selling conceptual photography — I call it that because I don't know how else to explain it — just as painting is sold. Painting, however, has centuries behind it and can withstand even the conceptual jokes, so to speak. And painting, because a painting is unique, can have financial value. It is a work that can be sold, but it remains one of a kind. A photograph, on the other hand, can be reproduced.
At present I don't know any photographer, except perhaps two or three in the entire world, who has become rich from photography. In Greece? Not a chance. At best you can make a living, and not everyone can do even that. So photography is now for those who love it. When one of my many students tires me out by asking my opinion, I say very simply, to get out of it, "What you are making, which in my opinion imitates painting in the worst possible way, is another kind of photography altogether, one I don't concern myself with."
For instance, someone makes provocative nude photographs, showing men and women from every angle. That has a different aim. It may even earn more money. The same applies to photography of events, which isn't needed in quite the way it once was. In the past there were photographs of that sort which, even if they were good, I wouldn't have chosen.
A child killed in a war, for instance, shown as he dies; a soldier dropping his rifle as he is shot. All that belongs to another understanding of photography. There were very good photographers who also earned their living through photography, taking fine photographs for newspapers, back in the old days — when I was born, more or less. But the value of those photographers wasn't in those images. It was in the photographs that said nothing.
When an event is of enormous importance, in other words, it overwhelms the photograph. And to put it even more forcefully, let me turn to painting. Picasso was a very great painter. His greatest period was his early period. Once he became very rich and knew that even a scribble on paper would be worth millions, he himself admitted that he began exploiting that public.
And the famous painting he made about the Spanish Civil War, the one everyone talks about, is a bad painting which merely exploits people's sentimentality. Picasso is great because of the first part of his painting. The rest — and he wrote this himself — was about exploiting the public and his own value. Well, photography has no commercial value. Even if you want to earn money, you won't. Young people should understand that. That sort of profession doesn't really exist any longer. So what remains is poetry.
Fortunately, poetry has never made money. I've often told my students, because it matters, the story of Seferis, who worked at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. He once told T. S. Eliot, "I want to give up my job and devote myself to poetry." Eliot replied, "No, that's a very dangerous thing. You mustn't devote yourself exclusively to poetry." And all the great poets had another job.
So I believe this is how we should look at photography too. Photography is a personal form of expression, with one very great advantage: the reality of memory. It is no accident that people forced to flee their homes took their family photographs with them in a little suitcase. So let us carry that value of poetry over into photography.
Now, another thing: as you learn more about photography, as you improve, one question people so often ask when you show a photograph — a question that feels like a knife in my heart — is, "Where is that?" When I used to show my work — I don't any more; I've stopped — people asked, "Where is that?" That's the first knife. And you think, "What does it matter to you where this tree is? Does its location count?" And at that point you'd better say nothing. They also ask, "What does it mean?"
I have held just one major exhibition in a well-known venue, to show my students that I wasn't against exhibitions. I never held another gallery exhibition after that. Of course some photographs sold, because I was already known, but I didn't do it again. The gallery wanted me to issue limited editions. I said, "I'll never do that. I don't recommend it, and fundamentally I'm against it." You know what limited editions mean? You declare, "I've made five prints of this photograph."
The women at the gallery very politely asked me, "And how shall we mark them?" This was revolutionary and many people criticised me for it. Photography is reproducible. Its value isn't in being unique. Its value is precisely that it can be reproduced. Those who make money from photography conceal that fact — and there are very few of them, making very little money.
I played another little trick at that exhibition. It was called "Quartets." A quartet means four, yes? And I said, "You will sell my photographs in groups of four, just as I present them." I take four photographs and say, "These are sold together." They weren't all alike — five windows, five women and so on, as one might expect. I deliberately mixed the photographs so that the buyer or viewer wouldn't get stuck on the subject matter, saying, "Oh, these are the women." "Rivellis's women," for instance.
I wanted to show them that a photograph is something more than what it shows, more than what it describes. That's why photography shouldn't be reductive. To give you some idea of what I had to contend with when I was still learning photography myself...
It was the early 1980s and I was giving a talk somewhere in Kolonaki. There were lots of experts there, many well-known photographers of the day who didn't think as I did. I was still rather naive. Among the images I showed was one that most of you probably know, by Cartier-Bresson, taken in Paris: a man leaps into the air to avoid landing in the water on a wet street.
I was explaining why the photograph was interesting, and a photographer — not a bad one, by the way, and I won't name him, a nice person, a good fellow — said kindly, not at all provocatively, "Why should we Greeks like this photograph?" I said, "Sorry, what do you mean?" He said, "It rains a lot in France. It doesn't here." My mouth fell open; I couldn't think how to end the conversation politely. So because Cartier-Bresson photographs a man jumping over puddles, and because we live farther south where it doesn't rain much, it has nothing to do with us!
And then you begin to understand how much groundwork is needed before potentially talented young people can develop. If you study for years at university to become a painter, or if you are a pianist, the constant practice will at least have taught you something.
When you're a photographer, however, professional or amateur, you can put on an exhibition from one day to the next, perhaps even publish a book. The other day a woman sent me something I always dread receiving: a little book she had made. She wrote me a very polite letter: "This is a gift for you; I admire you," and so on. I thanked her warmly. The book was childish and bad. Not bad in any malicious way, just naive, let's say. Unfortunately she wrote again to ask, "Could you comment on it?" And I thought, "Good Lord, what am I going to say?"
I called her and asked, "Have you been photographing for long?" I hoped she'd say, "I've just started." She said, "Ten years." So I asked a second question, hoping for something to hold on to! I imagined she might be a young girl. "How old are you, if you don't mind my asking?" "Oh, I'm young," she said, "fifty-five." And I thought, "Fifty-five and she's been photographing for ten years!" She added, "I have a teacher who used to be your student." She told me his name; all right, I understood. I spent half an hour on the telephone trying, as politely as I possibly could, to explain why her photographs weren't good.
She was very courteous to me, but I doubt she'll love me much now. I've lived with that ever since I began, because as a child I desperately wanted people to love me. When friends visited my parents, since I loved chocolate then and still do, I would offer them a chocolate and ask, "Do you love me?"
I'd dearly like to say nice things to everyone. But ever since I took up photography, even if the most beautiful woman in the world came and asked my opinion, I would give it honestly, without claiming anything was absolute. And that has cost me dearly in many ways. Once there was an exhibition at the Benaki Museum and they asked me to make the selection. People who weren't students of mine came along. I tell you this because it's a funny story. An extraordinarily beautiful young woman came to the Circle.
She came into my office — I had a little office then — and outside all the men in the Circle were beside themselves over her. She was truly beautiful. She showed me her photographs: enormous, glossy prints. Complete nonsense. I can't call them merely bad. They were nonsense. They weren't even childish; children's work isn't necessarily bad. Nonsense is something that imagines itself to be good. I didn't tell her my opinion.
I confined myself to deciding whether she could take part in the exhibition. So I said, "I'm sorry, the photographs don't fit the exhibition. I won't be able to include you."
Out of curiosity I asked, "May I ask something? What is it you like about your photographs? What exactly do you like?" And she calmly answered, "That they're glossy." At that point you throw up your hands and say, "Well, God has room for everyone." End of story. When she left, my students and friends said, "You didn't keep her?" "No, the photographs were dreadful." "You idiot! You mean we couldn't keep a girl that beautiful?" I said, "I'd have liked to, but glossy isn't enough for me."
You cannot argue with someone about something you see perfectly clearly when they tell you it isn't a scientific argument. If you like something, you like it; what can anyone say? But you must also be able to listen to someone else's opinion. Photography isn't a science. Even doctors aren't easy for us to judge. Unfortunately we often judge them after the fact.
You can't legislate what another person likes. You have to wait, gradually. None of us understood at the start what makes a good photograph, and nobody is obliged to agree with me, or anyone else, about which photograph is good. But you do have to trust the person you choose to follow.
The great joy of these last few years is that I now have students who keep going, little by little. From this year onward — I've already told my students and will announce it publicly — they've worried that I might retire because of my age. So I tell them, "You'll give up on me; I shall carry on until I start talking rubbish." I don't want any new students now. I have the ones I have. There is a large group of people who have followed me for years. A couple of years ago a difficult, rather peculiar young woman joined us. Difficult, peculiar people can be promising. She produced incredible rubbish.
And she was provocative as well. I was patient. The older students were tearing their hair out. The following year she returned. We were all amazed that she'd come back. But I must tell you that the next year she made astonishing progress, more than anyone expected. Difficult, awkward people often conceal a certain intelligence, and suddenly they work things out for themselves. Once you begin saying, "I'll keep this one, and this one, and this one," they start improving. At the beginning there is a thirst, made stronger by the ease of producing photographs.
Someone can't keep bringing you two hundred photographs! For instance, a wonderful new student of mine, who works in another field and lives in New York, sent me an enormous number. And when I say enormous, I mean she now bombards me, though previously she never took photographs at all! Bombards me with them. What can I say? She asks, "Shall I send you some?" "As many as you like." Last time she sent three hundred, followed by another two hundred, and I threw them out with the greatest ease. It didn't even tire me. Each time we have a little drama, a tender disappointment. "One day you'll laugh about this," I tell her.
The point is that you enjoy yourself. You will, and gradually you'll settle down. You'll pass through a rather hopeless phase, and slowly more work will begin to emerge. Another thing: you never know who's looking at your photographs, or how capable they are of understanding you. They may never have made a photograph in their life. Years ago I held an exhibition in Larissa. Among the visitors was an elderly man who, I later learned, played an instrument or had some unrelated occupation. I can't remember. He didn't know me. He saw the exhibition. There were various photographs, but no people.
Mostly buildings and objects, you know, rather austere photographs, I'd say. At the end he came to me and said, "Mr Rivellis, I enjoyed that so much. Such cheerful photographs!"
No one would have described those photographs as cheerful. But I didn't tell him, "They're not cheerful." I said, "You've moved me enormously." If he saw those photographs as cheerful and liked them, then I had succeeded. I don't set out to make cheerful or sad photographs.
And once I made the mistake of explaining a photograph. At the big exhibition I mentioned, I happened to be there — I lived on Syros and was just passing through. A woman who knew me said, "Platon, will you show me your photograph?" I felt I ought to say something. What? Some nonsense, just so I wouldn't stand there in silence. It was a photograph of a little plant, somewhere between a bush and a young tree, beside the water. So I said, purely for the sake of saying something, "It reminded me of a Tarkovsky film." I made some Christian-sounding remark. She was delighted and bought the work.
I thought, "If I sit here talking this sort of nonsense, they'll buy everything. All I need do is say something absurd and they'll buy it." What they want is an explanation. Another dear friend of mine, of my generation, a photographer and a thoroughly likeable person — not a student, but we love each other — had an exhibition. I avoid exhibitions precisely because I don't want people asking my opinion. And I can't lie. "Tell a little lie!" people say. But I can't. So I went to see it at the gallery early in the morning.
As I was leaving, in walked my friend. He hugged me — some former students of mine were with him — and asked, "What did you think?" I didn't know what to say. "Look, it's not my sort of thing. It isn't something I understand. I love you very much. Kisses, kisses." And I left. Do you know what he said to the others afterwards? We really are fond of each other, as I said. He said, "Well, there's one person who didn't like my work." Good for him, God bless him. The funny thing is that the work sold. He made money. So why should he believe me?
Now I'll tell you what the exhibition was. It had a concept. Do you know what that means? You decide on an idea in advance, then make the photographs fit it. He was a very fine craftsman and had filled the entire gallery with pictures of flies. You know, big flies, little flies, the ones that settle on walls. He had photographed masses of flies, large and small, printed them on transparencies and stuck them all around the gallery. Big flies, little flies. Black flies everywhere, big and little. I'm telling you, the whole gallery!
So far, all right, it's rather odd. I asked a question at the gallery: "Excuse me, how do you sell these flies? Does someone ask you to cut out five flies?" The answer was unbelievable; I hadn't thought of it. "No," they said, "you specify the wall you want to cover. These are intended to go into the buyer's home to decorate the living room. You say, 'My living room wall is so many metres by so many.' 'That will take this many flies; the flies cost so much; we charge you and you take them home.'" Is that bad? No, it's not bad.
But it overturns the whole idea of photography, what photography means. Is photography decoration? Let's agree that the flies are decoration. But is photography decoration? If it is, I know nothing about decoration. I can't teach photography. You see how muddled the whole thing becomes. So when someone comes and tells me, "I like this," I'm not going to argue. If someone comes, has the patience to listen to me, and stays, I'll be delighted, and I believe they'll benefit.
If you want to become rich, stay in law. Don't become a photographer. There's good money in law. And do you know why? When I was a lawyer, by some miracle a professor of mine recommended me to a lady as her lawyer. She was exceedingly polite and hired me straight away. It was a big case, and I was anxious about it. I handled it very well. A very big case indeed, important for someone my age and with my means. I was earning 50,000 drachmas a month at the time, which was a lot.
I went to the professor and said, "Professor, you recommended me, and I don't know how fees are set. Please tell me what to ask." He was a genuinely admirable and important man. He had a slightly crooked smile. He said, "What do you think?" I summoned the courage to say it aloud: "One million." A million drachmas was a mythical sum then. We're talking about some time in the 1970s, an enormous amount. He laughed a little and suggested a much higher fee.
I went to the client and asked, "Excuse me, are you satisfied?" "Very," she said. "Very satisfied, and thank you so much." I couldn't believe it. That's when things started going wrong for me. I began thinking, "This is where the money is. This is how people make money." I was on my way to becoming a high-powered lawyer. I was in danger of changing as a person. People began offering me enormous cases, most of them rather dubious. And I said, "This isn't going well." But it did me good to know I could earn money.
Then I said to myself, "If I carry on, not only will I never make photographs, I'll change my character too." My father had died, and reflecting on his life helped me. I went to my mother and said, "I'm leaving law, selling the car. We'll be under financial pressure." "Yes, my dear, do whatever you want. I trust you." And I stopped practising law overnight. Clients kept calling me. When I went to America, penniless, to study photography, they rang to offer me work. "I'm not a lawyer," I'd say. People still ask me for legal advice. I say, "I don't know."
When it comes to dealing with public authorities, I ask my wife to discuss it. I say, "I know nothing about bureaucracy." That's it. From then on I chose, spoiled or fortunate as I may be, to do what I wanted. But I'm certainly not going to do what I love with the aim of making money. I could earn far more, far more easily, in law! You earn money there and then become a photographer to earn money? Yet many students, to my great sadness, have said to me, "Yes, but you used to be a lawyer."
I say, "For heaven's sake!" What does it matter whether you used to be a lawyer or a doctor? Making a good photograph is a greater reward. So I now have students whom I might call eccentrics, but worthwhile eccentrics. Of course this isn't very sound commercially, but at my age it is far better than the life I had before, watching photographers struggle to listen to what I was saying.
There was once a large album about Greek photography, put together by people who had connections with the government. They didn't mention me anywhere, though I was already perhaps one of the most prominent names in photography. We're talking about the early 1990s, roughly ten years before I went to Syros.
They published a big volume which included photographers who had even exhibited with us, but my name was nowhere. Two students who loved me said, "See where all your nonsense got you? They left you out!" I couldn't have cared less! I didn't take photographs to get into that volume. To console them I said, "When I die, they'll remember me more." We cannot spend our lives worrying about how to get noticed, or how to make money. If money is what you want, choose that as your goal. Look, I respect people who want to make money. It's a perfectly reasonable ambition, but you have to live accordingly, keep company with the right people. Who are the clients who bring a law firm a lot of money? The ones you do good work for. As for me, I'd rather spend my life with the photographs of my good students.
So I tell you again, I'm going through a good period of my life. I don't want to speak to large audiences. I make exceptions. Because AI makes it easy, I translated my entire website, which contains a great deal, into English. And now people abroad contact me, wanting to meet and talk and all the rest.
Recently a German man wrote to me, evidently younger — probably much younger — and said, "I've read your work, I'm very interested, and I'd like to meet you." I must tell you, as an aside, that people under forty seem unable to understand what I do. Some are even aggressive. I don't read their comments myself. My students tell me what they read, because I don't go into social media comment threads. People gossip and insult me, because young people don't understand this kind of photography; they have other ideas.
Someone told me, "People over forty say wonderful things about you." But you can't let that be your guiding purpose. Well, someone wrote to me from Poland. I didn't answer. Another person actually came to Syros. I couldn't say, "I won't see you." He was a good man, pleasant enough. As I said, he had also done a podcast with me. Someone else wrote from Poland: "If you'd like us to get in touch..." I don't want to. I can't. It's work, it tires me out. I'm not at a stage in my life when I want to meet new people.
My students are enough for me, my home is enough, my wife is enough. I'm having a very good time. For as long as I can, yes? Well, that's more or less the story of an interesting life, I'd say, a daring life. I never had any guarantees. My only security was my parents and my wife. That was my security. I know most people suffer from insecurity within the family, personal insecurity, the need to prove to someone that they're somebody. And all of that is a tremendous burden.
I would never have called you myself to ask for a podcast. Afterwards I learned you'd interviewed various former students of mine, people who could have become better photographers than they did. All those I've seen had started out much better. But I understand that they wanted broader social recognition. And you can't have everything. You can't achieve both things. As you develop, your audience will grow more distant from you. Unless you become a huge celebrity.
You know how often, at the start of my career, fashionable society ladies asked me, "Mr Rivellis, since you know which photographers are good, could you recommend a few whose photographs I might buy?" I said, "No. I'm not an agent. If you like a photograph, buy it. I can't tell you whom to buy." Because I understood "who is good" to mean "whose work will increase in value later." I don't know that either. Buy whatever you like. Whatever you like. You see?
So if you make a few fundamental choices in life — and that's very difficult, really — the one choice I can't guarantee is whom you marry, woman or man. That's a lottery; God help you. And once you escape women and men alike, you're even freer! I'm ready to hear questions or details if you have any. Otherwise I'll stop, because if not, I'll talk until this evening.
Interviewer
Where do I begin? I've enjoyed every moment of this, Mr Rivellis. We haven't met, but I've come to know you through your books, your videos, your stories. As you know, many people I know have been your students. In fact, on Sunday I was at a dinner with photographers and a young woman said, "I'm a Rivellis person." So now there's even such a thing as a "Rivellis style" photographer.
Platon Rivellis
Yes, people do say that. Let me tell you something funny. One of my students, who took a completely different path from mine, still loves me and I love him. He visits me out of affection, not out of passion for photography. And he calls me "Dad." Imagine you calling me Dad! I feel that tenderness between us. For a long time he insisted that we made the same kind of photographs, though ours were entirely different. He wanted so badly for us to be family that I told him, "My boy, it's all right. We don't make the same photographs."
Unfortunately he studied abroad — I won't say where — and I believe it did him harm. His teacher, whom I knew very well, was a complete fool, and that did him harm too. But you know, when you go to a university, whichever university it is, you get whichever professor happens to be there. I've never heard of a truly great artist being a professor somewhere. Never. Garry Winogrand wasn't a professor. He was a photographer. He ran workshops. I never said workshops were a bad idea. But when you're at Yale, you're at Yale; you're not simply working with one particular teacher.
And someone once came from England. I had students who'd gone abroad, talked about me, and then people would come to see me when they visited Greece. This man was from the Royal College of Art. We talked at the Circle, and he said — I was rather more eloquent then, I spoke English and remembered it — "What you say is fascinating. We never say these things, we've never even heard them. Would you come and talk to us?" I said, "Thank you very much for the honour, but I don't want to. I know that's a different world."
A student of mine who didn't continue with photography had also gone to England and attended a class there. She showed some photographs and asked the professor for his opinion. He was astonished. "You want my opinion of your photographs?" She said, "Our teacher in Greece gives us his opinion of ours." Now pay attention to that. What you want from a teacher, above all — you see, we've opened another subject — is an opinion on photographs you've made and are uncertain about.
What artist doesn't doubt their art? Everyone has doubts. And let me digress again, so you can see how impulsive I am. I organised a major exhibition of Bruce Davidson. Bruce Davidson, whom I admired enormously. I contacted him, and the Hellenic American Union provided the money to invite him. We spoke on the telephone; he told me which photographs he wanted to include. I said, "I disagree. I admire and respect you, but I don't think that's the right selection." He said, "You make the selection."
I did. He was delighted. Very discreetly he asked, "May I add two photographs that I'm fond of?" "Of course! Absolutely!"
So we included his two as well. A little aside to show how funny it all is. A young man from the provinces, whom nobody knew, came to the opening and commented on two photographs. They were the very two the artist himself had asked to add. So what can you say?
Once we'd come to know each other well, we'd gone out and eaten together and so on, with Winogrand... Winogrand, sorry, Bruce Davidson; I've mixed them up. He said to his wife — sadly she has died, his daughter wrote to tell me — "I want to stay in Greece so I can have Platon critique my work."
Who said that? Davidson, a huge name! I told him, "Remember that the first photography book I ever bought was one of yours." But I'd donated all my books to the Benaki. So he gave me a book, two books. In one he wrote, "To Platon, my teacher." I said, "You, calling me your teacher?" I was astounded. But he had a point. Davidson had made... He gave me a thousand photographs for my archive. Very many weren't worth selecting. That doesn't mean he isn't a great photographer, but a photographer always needs someone outside himself to consult, someone who speaks the same language. Not necessarily someone with the same ability, you understand? Any artist is insecure. They wonder, "Now I've made this..."
Is it as worthwhile as the others?
Interviewer
Certainly.
Platon Rivellis
And that's when you need someone you trust, above all someone who speaks the same language. So when students I love change their aim, I won't quarrel with them, but I can no longer advise them.
Well, that student I mentioned, whom I still love very much and who calls me "Dad," went on to have a career. The first time he showed us his work — while insisting that we made the same kind of photographs, which is utterly wrong — he showed his pictures. I said nothing, out of affection, out of politeness. He had already graduated from a famous school. His photograph was very simple: a room's interior, just a wall and a chair. But you understand that when paths diverge, only affection remains. You can't give advice. Even if it is your own child, you'll love them even if they become a thief or a fraud.
They are your child. Anyway, he says, "What, you don't like this photograph?" I say, "What is there to like?" "Didn't you see the fly?" "The fly?" We all looked, the other students too. Up in the top right-hand corner of the room was a black fly on the wall. A huge colour photograph. I said, "I nearly brushed it away; I hadn't noticed it." This is what they call a concept. What does concept mean, what does gallery mean, what does any of it mean? It means the world of art has changed.
And today even a painter of real worth will struggle to sell paintings to whom? Not to the art collectors of the old days, the wealthy patrons all over the world who loved art, but to people who buy it as an investment and have no relationship with art at all.
Interviewer
It's become a business.
Platon Rivellis
It's become a business. A French photographer who bought photographs once said at an exhibition at the French Institute, years ago, "Please, photographers, don't make your prints so large; we can't fit them into our homes." But he forgot that big prints are also bought for corporate spaces. Ordinary people don't come along and buy enormous, terribly expensive photographs. Or collectors buy them and resell them. The art world has become something else.
And the people in it are different, you see? At least photography is inexpensive. You can do it on your own, in your own home, and enjoy the process. You don't have to spend lots of money or receive lots of money. Now you might say, "All these students of yours who became teachers — are they making money?" No, the poor souls! They all have some other job or receive help from their family or the state.
But do you know what it means to be a teacher? People look up at you, you're on a platform; it's something the family can be proud of. And yet, and yet... When I used to sign my name as "photography teacher," my wife's sweet father, now sadly deceased, said, "It's such a shame for him to call himself a photography teacher." "But he is a photography teacher," my wife replied. "Well, he could have said 'lawyer'." "But he isn't a lawyer!" How many of your parents thought that way? Most of them.
Interviewer
It's about status.
Platon Rivellis
It's tragic. Well, I've tired you out terribly. I'll stop for good now. I'll only answer questions; I won't say anything else, and I'll be as brief as I can. A difficult thing for me, but someone once said that the next version of Rivellis ought to come with a "stop" button. So let's press "stop."
Interviewer
Now for the questions. I have so many. But one thing stayed with me: you said that photographers under forty don't understand you. I wanted to ask how you see the new generation. Are they more educated, even if in photographic terms they are...
Students and the New Generation
Platon Rivellis
I don't know anything about the younger generation because I don't have children. And my friends are old.
Interviewer
Your students, I mean, your students?
Platon Rivellis
But I don't have students that young.
Interviewer
The woman who told me she was a "Rivellis person" was young.
Platon Rivellis
She's young. She's a student of mine.
Interviewer
She was a student. She was in the Circle.
Platon Rivellis
All right. Look, I may be a gifted speaker, and perhaps that's why she liked me. The question is what photographs I made and what criticism I offered. That's the test. I'm likeable, yes. I crack jokes, sometimes say something a little indecent, which people enjoy — I like to be rather free. But when it comes to criticism, that's where people are tested: how well can they bear a friend's criticism? Suppose a young woman comes to you in tears about her boyfriend and you say, "Hang on, you've made a mistake here. Perhaps you should consider that he might have a point too." She won't listen to you after that.
As for young people, I can't offer an opinion. But I feel anxiety and sadness. Only the other day there was the daughter of a student who very much wanted my opinion. I couldn't advise her, but I asked questions to find out more. I, for example, was an enthusiastic dancer from childhood. I loved dancing. Dancing was always my greatest pleasure. And all my first romantic encounters came through dancing. Back then, just to give you an example of how habits have changed, young people of my generation danced a great deal.
I don't know what our generation is called — baby boomers, I think. I danced from the time I was a little boy. Every weekend I was in love with a girl I'd danced with. What did we dance? Rock 'n' roll. I was a very good rock 'n' roll dancer. In rock you're some distance apart; you have a partner whose hands change position with yours. Your partner must know the steps too, because if she has no rhythm you curse the moment you chose her. Unfortunately my mother always said, "First dance once with every girl, and only then with the one you prefer."
As you can imagine, by the time I decided which girl I preferred, someone else had already claimed her! But when it was time for the slow dances — we called the slow songs "blues" — the lights went down, we embraced and began to talk. You don't talk when you're dancing rock. But when you're dancing in each other's arms, you move closer, you communicate. That's how you get to know a girl: you smell her hair, hold her a little tighter to see if she wants you to. It's all a lovely fairy tale. The twenty-year-olds I asked about this looked at me as though I were a zombie.
It doesn't happen. I say, "So what do you do?" "The girls dance on their own." "Holding hands?" "No, we jump about." There is no dance in which people embrace or move to each other's rhythm. That has changed completely. So communication has changed. Now communication means bars, drinks and talking. I say, "What do you mean?" The contact we imagined would become freer and more liberated has become worse than ever.
A student of mine who works with computers and follows these things told me that, over the last two years, young people's development has seemed to be getting worse, whereas previously each new generation was more advanced, better educated, more cultivated. I can't offer any further judgement, but a great deal of what I see makes me feel sad for them. Just look at the importance attached to degrees now. I try to explain to young people that I got a degree, earned money, but made my life on my own terms. When a young person tells me, "First I'll finish university, first I'll get..."
And note, university isn't enough any more. You need a master's degree too. Without a master's you're considered uneducated! Now, I don't know where AI is going. But I have something to say about it. At first I thought, "That's useful." Because I now have a problem with my memory, I can't remember names. When I read — even just now, when you said, "Read what it says" — I have trouble concentrating on the text. So writing and reading are more difficult, whereas I once wrote everything by hand.
So now I'm going to take advantage of AI. I'll start speaking to it and write my next book without having to write by hand. I always had a large callus on my hand from all the writing. That callus has disappeared. Look at my hand now: no callus at all. I don't write any more.
And because I write so much using the Latin alphabet, when I write by hand I mix up Greek and English letters. At my age I begin to get confused. So I said, I'll make use of AI. This year it's become extremely useful. But as I make new selections, things change. I said, "I don't want to stay only with the great photographers." I'm suspicious of Cartier-Bresson. He is a very great photographer, but a narcissist in the bad sense. I too am a narcissist in my talk! But he irritates me. Poor man, he's dead now, but he made both good photographs and superficial ones. Let's look at others, at others besides Cartier-Bresson, photographers we don't know. Let's look at people we've never heard of. So I search for photographers online. It's an enormous luxury for me: no need to buy books or spend money. I've found masterpieces, and I'm making new versions of my selections.
Obviously when I show photographs in my classes or to friends, I show sixty. I don't show the three hundred I have of each photographer. I choose the ones I want.
Interviewer
You couldn't.
Platon Rivellis
And now, while making those new selections, I'm discovering photographs by photographers I never knew. I've gathered work by several thousand photographers, with selections of photographs. I don't much care whether the reproduction online is accurate; I adjust the images myself so they look reasonably presentable and I use them for discussions with my students. In fact, I've listed most of them on my website — not all the photographs, that would be impossible, the number is vast — but I say, "These photographers are interesting," with four samples from each. It's interesting.
I'm not going to concern myself with the professionals or the conceptual artists. Good luck to them. I have nothing against them. I learned about them, and that's that. And the work gives me enormous pleasure. AI helps me. I'm not completely sure its information is entirely accurate. It might, for instance, attribute a photograph to the wrong photographer. Every so often I check whether I have the same photographs filed under different names. When there are conflicts, I investigate them so I can be honest. But I cannot guarantee that AI gives me the right information.
At some point I said, "Could AI help with the research?" I tried, together with a friend who knows more about it, to see what instructions we could give it. My friend was very funny. He said, "I want it to be a woman." And he told AI, "I want you to speak to me like a woman." The AI began explaining what a woman is. He said, "I know what a woman is; I want you to speak like one." So he addresses it, "Listen here, my dear," and says, "I want you to do this." He explains it as clearly as he can.
The AI says, "Yes, yes, yes, I understand, I'll do it." For example, I say, "I don't want photographers who resemble this one, or photographers who are the opposite of this one. Second, I want nothing conceptual and nothing obviously commercial, such as newspaper or advertising photography." I explain all of this, run thirty tests, and it sends back a jumble of everything! It simply couldn't understand the difference. When a distinction is abstract, it cannot grasp it. So there are things now...
It's rather like asking AI, "Can you tell me whether my wife loves me?" Well, it can't. Whatever you say to it, it cannot know. So AI is useful if you're capable of checking its answers. But now young people consult AI and then go to their doctors — doctors have told me this — and say, "Look, you're prescribing this medicine..." "Where did you read that?" "On AI." Do you know the consequences, and so on? Soon people will believe AI without question. And even older people say... Oh, what else did they tell me? No young woman falls in love any more — and unfortunately it's not only the young — or marries for love.
Everyone goes onto special platforms, says what they want, sees what's on offer, and that's how people meet. I must have heard this from a hundred young people.
Interviewer
Yes, that's true.
Photography in a Changing World
Platon Rivellis
So the world is changing. But it's changing without something more important or more valuable taking the place of what came before. I really don't know what to say. Perhaps I sound like an old man; I wouldn't rule that out. But I don't want to find a girlfriend through AI. I'd rather take a chance with my own life, toss a coin, so to speak.
Interviewer
Mr Rivellis, now that you're looking at so many photographers, how do you see Greek photography today?
Platon Rivellis
If I look at the small number who are my own students, I'm always optimistic. Beyond that, it makes sense that the majority should make bad photographs — in my opinion, always — because I know how difficult photography is, and I know there's always an ambition to be seen to be doing something.
Interviewer
But that's a motivation, I think. Not just money.
Platon Rivellis
Even wanting to appeal to girls is a motivation. You say, "I'm a teacher." Isn't it easier to meet a girl when you're a teacher? All of that is understandable. Now, who is good and who isn't... You know, for a very long time — I don't go anywhere now — people invited me to exhibition openings. I always politely declined. Always. Because at an opening you can only say complimentary things. And if you go there wanting to help the person by offering advice, they'll get angry or upset, at the very least.
So there's no point.
Interviewer
Yes, because that's why they've gone there: to hear nice things, things they like.
Platon Rivellis
That's what they want, that's what they want. What can I say to a photographer to whom I wrote pages and pages trying, as politely as possible, to explain that their work isn't good? It's not anything dreadful, but it's a dead end, it's nonsense, it achieves nothing. And then they have made a book as well, which costs money. However cheaply you print it, it costs something. And you think, "Why?" Why must you make a book at all costs?
It's good to make a book if you've been photographing for a long time. Not in order to sell it, because books rarely sell. Mine sold because I was known. I don't think it's worth printing fewer than a thousand copies, because below that the costs are almost the same. If you print five hundred instead of a thousand, the difference is very small — just the paper. Everything else is the same. And you wonder, "Should I print all those copies just to leave them sitting on a shelf?"
Because I'm known and have so many students, old and new, my books sell. But think of this: I saw that Davidson had published a wonderful book in a run of three thousand copies. It's astonishing to be Bruce Davidson in New York and publish only three thousand copies! I used to print three thousand myself in the beginning. Photography books don't sell. And he had sponsors. All right, I found sponsors too. It simply wasn't possible to sell such a book in large numbers.
At Eleftheroudakis, the bookshop where I supplied my books, they told me, "If a photography book has no subject, it never sells." Put it in the section labelled "Photography," and it never sells — even if it says "Bresson" on the cover. Put "cats" or "nudes" on it and it will sell immediately. You see? That's how it is. That's life, that's money. Don't get angry about it. Make your own choice. But I repeat: if you want money and you're depending on photography to get it, you're a fool. Absolutely!
Interviewer
And may I add one more thing?
Platon Rivellis
This is a difficult truth, for young people and for everyone: if you want to become a university professor, you must be obsessed with study. Because the money you'll earn as a professor is far less than you could earn with a little cleverness in business. So why insist on going into academia? For two reasons: to enjoy the social prestige of being a professor, and to have job security. It doesn't mean you're wiser.
When every parent dreams of a child becoming a lawyer, a doctor or a university professor, what do you expect? The child grows up with that mentality. When you're fortunate enough to have parents like mine, who say, "Whatever you do, my child, you'll do it well," and who never worried... What other mother would accept her son saying, "I'm giving up the law, which makes a fortune, and setting off into the unknown with nothing but hope to guide me"? I don't know whether anyone is complaining that I've tired you out.
Interviewer
Not at all.
Platon Rivellis
After all, whoever wants to can skip past it.
Interviewer
Yes, exactly. So I'll ask one last question. You said that...
Platon Rivellis
I notice with pleasure that you said "last question." I thought, "I'll make him stop!"
Interviewer
No, no, I mean for your sake. I could keep going. You said that if you'd remained in law you would have had to change your character, whereas photography has certainly changed you. How do you think it changed you?
Platon Rivellis
Photography. I told you. You see, when I began, fortunately — everything has a balance we don't control — I started quite logically, like anyone in my position, practising law. I knew how to do it and had realised it didn't interest me, but I earned money. And the money came in.
But I realised I was beginning to change for the worse, and I was sending my assistant to court in my place. So I couldn't go on like that, however much I earned. And because I had no great insecurities, that was the good part. That's what parents can give you. Parents can't do anything more important than that.
They can say to their child what mine said to me: "Don't worry, my child, you'll manage." If you're insecure, you think, "Why take the risk? I'm making money here." Imagine if I'd had two or three children by then! I'd still have changed course. The children were spared that, luckily! So I had no problem. No problem choosing. I'd simply say, "I'm not enjoying my life. If I can do something else..." And let me say again: my parents at first had a good business. It went under, like so many businesses that make bad decisions.
My father was much more a man of art and music than of commerce. Business is terribly hard. You can make two mistakes and be ruined. And in those days there were no tricks; you couldn't simply say, "I'll declare bankruptcy." You'd be disgraced in society. So I learned to live as a young man without much money. Because if I'd had a fortune when I was young, who knows what a little bastard I'd have become? There's no guarantee I would have been a good person. You understand?
So things often happen in this way, and afterwards I try to explain — though nobody learns from someone else's experience — that you should do what you enjoy, do what you love. Do you love plants? You don't have to go to university. Why become a photographer? Why must you become a professional photographer? You know that when I started, people fought me hard and tried to deny the name "photographer" to anyone who wasn't a professional.
Interviewer
Why?
Platon Rivellis
I wrote three extremely harsh criticisms, almost attacks, in Ta Nea. Everyone turned against me. A very well-known photographer even publicly mocked my position at a meeting with the minister. They were all professionals, whereas I wasn't. In fact I made a mistake myself at first, which I later corrected and apologised for: I had described myself as a "professor of photography." That was wrong.
I say, "The only real teacher I had was a man who taught me in primary school, whom I mention in my book. He taught me to read and write." But when you say "professor," the family feels better. I will always prefer the title "teacher."
Interviewer
All right, I understand.
Platon Rivellis
You have no idea how anxious my wife is that I've tired you out. I tell her every time, "That's how I am." So ask any other questions you wish, if you have them.
Interviewer
No, I think we're fine. I think you've said everything.
Platon Rivellis
If I've said everything, I've even saved you the breath it would have taken to ask! I think I have said it all. And if you have a personal question for me, give me a call. I'm very happy you included me in your collection.
Interviewer
No, the honour is mine. As I said, you're an important chapter in the history of Greek photography. You've influenced us enormously.
Platon Rivellis
May I ask an odd question? Do you yourself take photographs, even just for the pleasure of it? Do you enjoy it? Do you enjoy making photographs?
Interviewer
I do, and I suppose I'm like everybody else. I go out, take photographs, enjoy myself for the first month, then the doubts return. I go out again, photograph again...
Platon Rivellis
That's exactly right.
Interviewer
Actually I am a photographer. I've worked professionally, though I've reduced that now; I work more as an engineer. I've managed to choose jobs that give me more freedom to go out and photograph.
Platon Rivellis
Bravo. Even when you do something very practical, if you have a good client who understands what you're doing, it gives you pleasure. You see? That's the point. Of course. And having good clients is a matter of luck, too. Everything matters in life, you understand?
Interviewer
Of course.
Platon Rivellis
That's why at some point I said, "I don't want this." A student came along last year to join a class. Recently there have been several people like that, and it's very difficult to join a class where everyone else has moved so far ahead. He said, "I've taken courses, I've made books, I live in America, I'm an actor." He had an extraordinary air of superiority.
He stood there with his mouth open. I told him, "You may be right, but I can't discuss it with you. You have a completely different mentality, and you'll tire out everyone else here." He was furious. I said, "I'll give you your money back. I know which bank you paid it into." The next day he wrote, "If you don't return my money immediately, I'll go to a lawyer." "I told you I'd return it the next day." And I thought, "Thank goodness I've escaped!" I don't want something I love to become a source of trouble. So now I've decided I want to work with people I can communicate with. If one of my good students says, "I know someone worth taking on," I'll make the effort to accept them, though with a little trepidation.
Interviewer
Well, Mr Rivellis, thank you very much. It was truly an honour to speak with you. How shall I put it? Everything I've read...
Platon Rivellis
I hope I haven't tired you out.
Interviewer
Not at all. Truly, if I could ask you questions for another five hours, I would.
Platon Rivellis
All right.
Interviewer
Thank you very much. I wish you all the best, and I hope you continue enjoying photography as you do now.
Platon Rivellis
Thank you very much. And please thank your partner too, who helped us. Thank you.